an ethnography of a situation that we, as Euro-American,
post-industrialized, individualistic, people both recognize and
abhor:
Benares (India) where one can fnd "joint families" (three
generation households keeping together parents, brothers and their wives
and children, and unmarried sisters) with strict controls on women in
their relations to people outside the household and complex division of
labor within the household.
- Note that the social situation within the household is more
complex than the features would imply: structuring is not simply a
matter of gender but certainly also one of age and the play of other
"resources" (from the "honor" of the family of
origin of each of the marrying in women, to education, etc.)
- One might want to identify this to what Parsons and others called
the "traditional" family. It is also one version of
what Goody associates with
"plow" agriculture.
- While some of the features can easily be generalized to large
areas of Eurasia, one must notice that
- this exact form has not been common in Europe for centuries,
if ever
- the way this works is heavily mediated by a religious ideology
embodied in a set of complex institutions that are specific not
simply to India, but to only one group within India (albeit the
larges): the caste system.
- note finally that Goody never quite explains what would be the
ecological constraints that would explain the rationality of an
extended family system in urban centers where survival is not
dependent on land but rather on the delivery of a service to
neighbors near and far.